Gingrich spokesman defends Wikipedia edits

Comm director has made, requested dozens of changes

Author: Gregory Wallace CNN
Published On: Feb 06 2012 12:33:11 PM EST  Updated On: Feb 06 2012 12:57:16 PM EST
Newt Gingrich takes SC

Eric Thayer/Reuters

(CNN) -

As recently as last week, Newt Gingrich's communications director has been criticized by editors on Wikipedia for dozens of edits he has made and requested in defense of his candidate.

While some of the changes were minor, Joe DeSantis has removed or asked to remove factual references to Gingrich's three marriages as well as mentions of ethics charges brought against him while he served as speaker of the House. These efforts continued as recently as Monday.

Wikipedia records show DeSantis has made over 60 adjustments to entries in the online, publicly-edited encyclopedia to the biographical entry on Gingrich, the similar page on his wife, Callista, and a separate page on one of their books, Rediscovering Good in America.

DeSantis has actively lobbied for changes to the articles since mid-December in a discussion forum called "Talk" on the site, and previously from May to June of last year, though his most recent direct edit to the site was in June of 2011.

Last Tuesday, DeSantis drew the ire of an editor on the site.

"I'll raise the question in the appropriate place, but I have to say this micro-managing by a Gingrich campaign director is a matter of concern to me even though you now are identifying yourself. Pointing out factual errors is one thing, but your input should not go beyond that, even here on Talk," the editor known as Tvoz, wrote on a page devoted discussing possible edits.

The site has a conflict of interest guideline which suggests that individuals should not edit "on behalf of clients," or on subjects to which they have "close relationships" or "financial interest." But the site does allow "non-controversial edits," and DeSantis has a profile on the site which identifies his relationship to Gingrich.

DeSantis defended his changes in a statement:

"I stopped making direct edits in May 2011 because I was alerted to the COI rules," he said. "Earlier I thought that simply disclosing my affiliation was enough but it wasn't. So I started posting requests on the Talk page.

"This has been far more successful and the other editors on Wikipedia have largely received this very positively," he continued.

But several editors on the site have taken issue with his edits and requests.

"The fact that Callista is Speaker Gingrich's third wife is well-known and indisputable. Please do not remove it from her biography," wrote editor Cullen328. "Instead, please defer to the judgment of experienced editors, and raise your concerns on the talk page. Thank you."

But other editors have been more sympathetic, voicing their appreciation of DeSantis' disclosure of his affiliation.

"Many editors have pointed out your straightforwardness as an example of honorable editing by an agent," an editor known as Buster Seven posted. "I agree with their assessment."

DeSantis' edits, which began in October of 2008, included rewriting, removing, and editing lines, including several edits to references of Gingrich's marriages, according to Wikipedia edit records, which are published and publicly viewable on the site. The edits may include repairing "vandalism," such as incorrect or biased information, posted to the articles.

From the introduction to an article on Callista, DeSantis struck: "She met her husband met while he was in the House, and had an affair while he was conducting the impeachment investigation for President Bill Clinton."

On a separate occasion, he removed lines about Gingrich's first divorce and remarriage which said he approached his then-wife in the hospital following surgery.

"Newt came up there with his yellow legal pad, and he had a list of things on how the divorce was going to be handled. He wanted her to sign it. She was still recovering from surgery," the article read.

When a $500,000 credit line held by Gingrich at luxury retailer Tiffany's made headlines, references to the account were added on Wikipedia, and DeSantis edited those references, including material supportive of his client published in news articles.

In April 2009, he deleted several lines on a House ethics investigation of Gingrich, replacing them with material more favorable to the former House speaker.

DeSantis adjusted language describing his boss' position on waterboarding and climate change. Another edit corrected the name of the church choir of which Callista is a member.

Minutes after posting his first edit to the site - which reworded the characterization of one of Gingrich's books - DeSantis created a user profile where he disclosed that he is employed by Gingrich. He also disclosed his connection to Gingrich in a note accompanying the first edit.

"I am the Communications Director for Former House Speaker Newt Gingrich," he wrote on the profile. "I created this profile to submit edits to his article while being fully open about my affiliation."

The site discourages edits by individuals with an interest in public understanding of the subject, but says an "editor with a self-evident interest in the matter turning up on the talk page is an indication that they are playing it straight."

Talk pages are editorial discussions within the Wikipedia community, and in the months since his most recent edit to the site, DeSantis has posted almost 50 times on these pages.

Advertisement

Election Video

Rick Daugherty (acceptance speech) extended

Democratic Nominee, 15th Congressional Dist.

Interview: Tom Smith

Republican Nominee, U.S. Senate

Tom Smith (acceptance speech)

Republican Nominee, U.S. Senate

Steve Welch (concession speech)

Republican Candidate, U.S. Senate

Jackson Eaton (concession speech)

Democratic Candidate, 15th Congressional Dist.

Matthew Cartwright (acceptance speech)

Democratic Nominee, 17th Congressional Dist.

Interview: Dr. Tim Blessing

Political Analyst, Alvernia University

Tim Holden (concession speech)

Tim Holden (concession speech)

Democratic Candidate, U.S. Senate

Sam Rohrer (concession speech)

Republican Candidate, U.S. Senate

Interview: Dr. James Peterson

Political Analyst, Lehigh University

Interview: Jack Cartwright

Son of Matt Cartwright, Cartwright for U.S. House 17th Dist.

Interview: Mike Schlossberg

Democratic Nominee, PA 132nd Legislative District

Interview: Robert Kerr

Chairman, Northampton Co. Republican Committee

Interview: Sam Rohrer

Republican Candidate, U.S. Senate

Interview: Dr. Chris Borick

Political Analyst, Muhlenberg College

Interview: Shane Seaver

Campaign Manager, Cartwright for U.S. House 17th Dist.

Interview: Tim Holden (Inc.)

US Congress, 17th District (D)

Interview: John Werkheiser

Supporter, Daugherty for U.S. House 15th Dist.

Interview: Michael Donovan

Democrat, Former Allentown City Council

Interview: Zac Moryle

Campaign Manager, Rohrer for U.S. Senate

Interview: Mark Harris

Consultant, Smith for U.S. Senate

Pa. primary to provide test run of photo ID law

Pennsylvania voters should expect to be asked for photo identification in Tuesday's primary election, but those without it won't be barred from casting ballots.

New Congressional districts set for primary election

New Congressional districts set for primary election

In case you forgot or got confused by the redistricting process, you will be voting in new U.S. House Districts Tuesday.

Democratic Congressional candidates go head-to-head

The two democrats running for the chance to face Republican incumbent Charlie Dent for the 15th Congressional Seat in November squared off in a debate Tuesday night.

NAACP helps inform voters about new Voter ID laws

Pennsylvania's voter ID law is only a month old, but local leaders say now is the time to educate yourself on what you'll need to cast your ballot.

Romney and Gingrich stump at GOP dinner in Lancaster

The political spotlight has shifted to Pennsylvania.

Two Democrats duke it out for a shot at Congressman Dent's seat

Two Democrats duke it out for a shot at Congressman Dent's seat

Two Democratic challengers say they have the right stuff to unseat incumbent Republican Charlie Dent in Pennsylvania's 15th District.

Dems, GOP reaching out to Latino voters

Dems, GOP reaching out to Latino voters

Most Recent On WFMZ.COM

Advertisement
WFMZ-TV on Facebook

Links We Like

    from our sponsors