Hoekstra won't apologize for Super Bowl ad

Ad debuted in Michigan markets

Author: By Lisa Sylvester CNN Correspondent
Published On: Feb 06 2012 05:29:43 PM EST  Updated On: Feb 06 2012 07:01:17 PM EST
Peter Hoekstra

Hoekstra for Senate

(CNN) -

In the political world, it was the most talked-about ad from Sunday night's Super Bowl telecast. Pete Hoekstra, running for Senate in Michigan against incumbent Debbie Stabenow, hit the Democrat for her record on spending. But some are criticizing the spot for being blatantly racist.

The 30-second ad features a young Asian woman riding a bike through rice paddies speaking in unaccented but broken English:

"Thank you, Michigan Senator Debbie Spenditnow," the woman said. "Debbie spend so much American money. You borrow more and more from us. Your economy get very weak. Ours get very good. We take your jobs. Thank you, Debbie Spenditnow."

The ad debuted during the Super Bowl in Michigan television markets, and is accompanied with a website that includes Chinese characters and titles like the "Great Wall of Debt."

The ad is being lambasted by critics who call its depiction of the Asian woman racist.

In an interview with CNN Monday, Hoekstra defended the spot. Responding to allegations of racism, Hoekstra said "I don't think there's any element of that at all."

He added, "The only stereotyping is of liberal Democrats and their spending polices."

But the response from viewers who saw the ad, including fellow Republicans, was swift.

Republican strategist Mike Murphy tweeted, "Pete Hoekstra Superbowl TV ad in MI Senate race really, really dumb. I mean really."

And a group of Detroit Baptist ministers are calling on Hoekstra to apologize and pull the ad.

"If he would say these types of things, and use these types of actions, using Asians, than we believe the same fear tactics will be presented in this regard to African-Americans," civil rights leader Rev. Charles Williams II said at a press conference Monday.

The ad was reportedly produced by Fred Davis of Strategic Perception. He's the same ad man behind the now infamous "I'm not a witch" ad by former Delaware Senate candidate Christine O'Donnell. Davis purposely goes for ads that are attention getting.

In fact, Hoekstra was the target of an ad campaign produced by Davis in 2010 during a run for Michigan governor. The spots, produced by Republican opponent Rick Snyder, presented Snyder as "one tough nerd" while painting Hoekstra as a career politician.

The ad's effectiveness sparked Hoekstra to hire Davis to produce a hard-hitting for his own campaign.

Despite the uproar, Hoekstra has no intention of backing down.

"No, I'm not apologizing for the ad," Hoekstra said. "If someone believes that we were insensitive, I'm sorry to them. But I'm not apologizing for this ad at all. I think it clearly drives the message. The problem is American public policy, it's not what the Chinese are doing at all."

Hoekstra centered a fundraising email to supporters around the ad Monday, writing "Here we go again. We dared to take on Debbie Stabenow and China, and the liberals are doing what they always do-crying racism."

The email directs readers to Hoekstra's campaign website, where they can contribute money to his election effort.

Senator Stabenow's campaign office referred requests for comment to the Michigan Democratic Party, which pointed to Hoekstra's own record of voting to increase the national debt ceiling and for the bailout of Wall Street.

Mark Brewer, chairman of the Michigan Democratic Party, said is the ad was backfiring.

"It was shot in the United States," Brewer said. "I understand the actress is an American. It's just hypocrisy and just so insincere. I think it just adds to Pete Hoekstra's credibility problems."

Advertisement

Election Video

Rick Daugherty (acceptance speech) extended

Democratic Nominee, 15th Congressional Dist.

Interview: Tom Smith

Republican Nominee, U.S. Senate

Tom Smith (acceptance speech)

Republican Nominee, U.S. Senate

Steve Welch (concession speech)

Republican Candidate, U.S. Senate

Jackson Eaton (concession speech)

Democratic Candidate, 15th Congressional Dist.

Matthew Cartwright (acceptance speech)

Democratic Nominee, 17th Congressional Dist.

Interview: Dr. Tim Blessing

Political Analyst, Alvernia University

Tim Holden (concession speech)

Tim Holden (concession speech)

Democratic Candidate, U.S. Senate

Sam Rohrer (concession speech)

Republican Candidate, U.S. Senate

Interview: Dr. James Peterson

Political Analyst, Lehigh University

Interview: Jack Cartwright

Son of Matt Cartwright, Cartwright for U.S. House 17th Dist.

Interview: Mike Schlossberg

Democratic Nominee, PA 132nd Legislative District

Interview: Robert Kerr

Chairman, Northampton Co. Republican Committee

Interview: Sam Rohrer

Republican Candidate, U.S. Senate

Interview: Dr. Chris Borick

Political Analyst, Muhlenberg College

Interview: Shane Seaver

Campaign Manager, Cartwright for U.S. House 17th Dist.

Interview: Tim Holden (Inc.)

US Congress, 17th District (D)

Interview: John Werkheiser

Supporter, Daugherty for U.S. House 15th Dist.

Interview: Michael Donovan

Democrat, Former Allentown City Council

Interview: Zac Moryle

Campaign Manager, Rohrer for U.S. Senate

Interview: Mark Harris

Consultant, Smith for U.S. Senate

Pa. primary to provide test run of photo ID law

Pennsylvania voters should expect to be asked for photo identification in Tuesday's primary election, but those without it won't be barred from casting ballots.

New Congressional districts set for primary election

New Congressional districts set for primary election

In case you forgot or got confused by the redistricting process, you will be voting in new U.S. House Districts Tuesday.

Democratic Congressional candidates go head-to-head

The two democrats running for the chance to face Republican incumbent Charlie Dent for the 15th Congressional Seat in November squared off in a debate Tuesday night.

NAACP helps inform voters about new Voter ID laws

Pennsylvania's voter ID law is only a month old, but local leaders say now is the time to educate yourself on what you'll need to cast your ballot.

Romney and Gingrich stump at GOP dinner in Lancaster

The political spotlight has shifted to Pennsylvania.

Two Democrats duke it out for a shot at Congressman Dent's seat

Two Democrats duke it out for a shot at Congressman Dent's seat

Two Democratic challengers say they have the right stuff to unseat incumbent Republican Charlie Dent in Pennsylvania's 15th District.

Dems, GOP reaching out to Latino voters

Dems, GOP reaching out to Latino voters

Most Recent On WFMZ.COM

Advertisement
WFMZ-TV on Facebook

Links We Like

    from our sponsors