Romney email omits Detroit News criticism

Press release includes praise but no negatives

Author: By CNN Political Unit
Published On: Feb 22 2012 04:50:04 PM EST  Updated On: Feb 23 2012 04:14:52 AM EST
Mitt Romney Maine win announcement

(CNN) -

Touting an endorsement from The Detroit News, Mitt Romney's campaign sent out a press release announcing the news Wednesday morning.

But the e-mail skipped over a few key paragraphs in the editorial, namely sentences that offered criticism of the Republican presidential candidate.

While much of the article lauded Romney as the most experienced and electable candidate, the editorial board included a few points of contention:

"We disagree with Romney on a point vital to Michigan - his opposition to the bailout of the domestic automobile industry. Romney advocated for a more traditional bankruptcy process, while we believe the bridge loans provided by the federal government in the fall of 2008 were absolutely essential to the survival of General Motors Corp. and Chrysler Corp."

But the editorial board went on to write that the issue "wasn't a differentiator in the GOP primary, since the entire field opposed the rescue effort."

The Romney press release, however, replaced that section with a simple:

"..."

Other paragraphs replaced with ellipses included the board's analysis on the volatile presidential race, naming several candidates "who have enjoyed a burst of popularity at Romney's expense." The article also mentioned that "very conservative Republicans have been lukewarm to Romney because of his history of more moderate positions on social issues."

That, too, was left out of the Romney email.

To be fair, the release omitted harsh criticism of his opponents, Rick Santorum and Newt Gingrich, as well. The release also included a link to the full story at the top of the email.

The Detroit News' editorial page editor, Nolan Finley, said he contacted the Romney campaign after media reports highlighted the press release.

"We would prefer -- if they are going to excerpt pieces of the editorial and not the complete editorial -- that they would have indicated that they were excepts," he told CNN. "This was such a long cut and paste that I think it did create some confusion as to whether this was the whole editorial or not."

The Romney campaign told him they circulated excerpts, rather than the full text, because of copyright "legal concerns," Finley said, and he was assured a link to the full text did and would accompany any excerpts.

This isn't the first time Romney's campaign has carved out negative commentary when sending out newspaper endorsements (of which Romney has many). It left out similar critical passages in its release on The Des Moines Register endorsement in December, for example, as well as an editorial from The Tampa Bay Times in January.

While copyright laws may play a role in restricting the amount of material a campaign can legally disseminate, the email blasts leave out largely negative material. In the case of The Detroit News, the campaign skipped over the primary point of criticism on Romney's opposition of the auto bailouts, a big issue in Michigan.

Advertisement

Election Video

Rick Daugherty (acceptance speech) extended

Democratic Nominee, 15th Congressional Dist.

Interview: Tom Smith

Republican Nominee, U.S. Senate

Tom Smith (acceptance speech)

Republican Nominee, U.S. Senate

Steve Welch (concession speech)

Republican Candidate, U.S. Senate

Jackson Eaton (concession speech)

Democratic Candidate, 15th Congressional Dist.

Matthew Cartwright (acceptance speech)

Democratic Nominee, 17th Congressional Dist.

Interview: Dr. Tim Blessing

Political Analyst, Alvernia University

Tim Holden (concession speech)

Tim Holden (concession speech)

Democratic Candidate, U.S. Senate

Sam Rohrer (concession speech)

Republican Candidate, U.S. Senate

Interview: Dr. James Peterson

Political Analyst, Lehigh University

Interview: Jack Cartwright

Son of Matt Cartwright, Cartwright for U.S. House 17th Dist.

Interview: Mike Schlossberg

Democratic Nominee, PA 132nd Legislative District

Interview: Robert Kerr

Chairman, Northampton Co. Republican Committee

Interview: Sam Rohrer

Republican Candidate, U.S. Senate

Interview: Dr. Chris Borick

Political Analyst, Muhlenberg College

Interview: Shane Seaver

Campaign Manager, Cartwright for U.S. House 17th Dist.

Interview: Tim Holden (Inc.)

US Congress, 17th District (D)

Interview: John Werkheiser

Supporter, Daugherty for U.S. House 15th Dist.

Interview: Michael Donovan

Democrat, Former Allentown City Council

Interview: Zac Moryle

Campaign Manager, Rohrer for U.S. Senate

Interview: Mark Harris

Consultant, Smith for U.S. Senate

Pa. primary to provide test run of photo ID law

Pennsylvania voters should expect to be asked for photo identification in Tuesday's primary election, but those without it won't be barred from casting ballots.

New Congressional districts set for primary election

New Congressional districts set for primary election

In case you forgot or got confused by the redistricting process, you will be voting in new U.S. House Districts Tuesday.

Democratic Congressional candidates go head-to-head

The two democrats running for the chance to face Republican incumbent Charlie Dent for the 15th Congressional Seat in November squared off in a debate Tuesday night.

NAACP helps inform voters about new Voter ID laws

Pennsylvania's voter ID law is only a month old, but local leaders say now is the time to educate yourself on what you'll need to cast your ballot.

Romney and Gingrich stump at GOP dinner in Lancaster

The political spotlight has shifted to Pennsylvania.

Two Democrats duke it out for a shot at Congressman Dent's seat

Two Democrats duke it out for a shot at Congressman Dent's seat

Two Democratic challengers say they have the right stuff to unseat incumbent Republican Charlie Dent in Pennsylvania's 15th District.

Dems, GOP reaching out to Latino voters

Dems, GOP reaching out to Latino voters

Most Recent On WFMZ.COM

Advertisement
WFMZ-TV on Facebook

Links We Like

    from our sponsors